| May 22, 2003
Via email: mds30comments@cms.hhs.gov
Rita Shapiro
Division of Ambulatory and Post Acute Care (DAPAC)
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services
7500 Security Boulevard, Mail Stop S3-02-01
Baltimore, MD 21244
Re: Town Hall Meeting on Refinement of the
Minimum Data Set (MDS), Version 3.0
The American Therapeutic
Recreation Association (ATRA) represents recreational
therapists providing treatment services to Medicare
beneficiaries in the United States. The U.S. Department
of Labor estimates there are over 29,000 individuals
employed as recreational therapists in the country.
Recreational therapists provide active treatment
services that are part of an interdisciplinary plan
of care, have a reasonable expectation of improving
the patient’s condition and are supervised
by a physician. In addition, recreational therapists
are recognized as qualified rehabilitation therapists
by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare
Organizations (JCAHO) and CARF… The Rehabilitation
Accreditation Commission.
ATRA is pleased to
provide our general comments regarding the refinement
of the MDS 3.0.
1. MDS 3.0 General
Comments:
a. ATRA applauds
CMS for the recognition of recreational therapy
as an ordered therapy and the placement of such
in Section P 2. “Therapies” section.
This is consistent with current practice, the industry
and accrediting agency standards.
b. The recognition
of Quality of Life indicators is an important addition,
however the current structure of questions does
not accurately address quality of life measures.
ATRA will provide specific comments regarding the
Quality of Life indicators below.
c. Varying assessment
windows as well as assessment scales will lead to
confusion and uncertainty. Recommend a consistent
assessment window to increase accuracy of the MDS.
d. With several changes
in the MDS 3.0, the user manual or interpretive
instructions will need to be revised to reflect
current practice. ATRA willingly supports these
revisions and stands ready to assist in the manual
revisions.
2. Specific Comments on MDS 3.0:
Section F.
a. Quality of Life
indicators are an important addition to the MDS
and will assist in providing a true picture of resident’s
well-being (or perception of). ATRA recommends the
Quality of Life indicators be revised to reflect
current research in this area, including observable,
non-verbal, and/or non-expressed resident behaviors
and responses. ATRA will provide specific examples
based on our literature review following the Town
Hall meeting.
Sections G and K.
The use of the FIM
related language and seven point scale is excellent
for consistency and follow up with patients throughout
the spectrum of care, however the change from a
four point scale in other areas of the MDS 3.0 to
the seven point scale may be confusing and lead
to inaccurate ratings.
Section N.
The incorporation
of MDS 2.0 Sections F and E are positive to reflect
involvement patterns however without access to the
user manual, Section N5. Pursuit and Engagement
does not provide enough distinctions between the
two statements.
Section P.
Section P1. “Special
Treatments, Procedures and Programs, r. Training
in skills required to return to community”
is a significant measure that may be impacted by
the interventions by qualified therapists, including
recreational therapists. The user manual should
be revised to reflect qualified therapists within
their respective scope of practice.
Section P2. “Therapies”
Utilize the most
cost effective mix of rehabilitation therapies,
including recreational therapy, as identified in
Section P2. to determine the rehabilitation RUG
classification level.
Section P2. Retain
the definitions for all therapies identified in
Section P2. Current definitions include physician
ordered therapy, the order includes frequency, intensity
and duration of therapy, and the therapy is provided
by a qualified therapist (provider).
Section T.
Section T1. Ordered
Therapies
Include recreational
therapy in the list of ordered therapies to remain
consistent with language in Section P2 and industry
practice.
3. ATRA requests
an opportunity to address their specific comments
regarding the Quality of Life indicators at the
Town Hall meeting on June 2, 2003. Both myself and
Dawn DeVries are registered to attend.
4. Thank you for
the opportunity to review and provide comments to
the proposed rules and regulations regarding the
Town Hall Meeting on the Refinement of the MDS 3.0.
If you seek clarification relative to our comments,
please contact Ann D. Huston, MPA, CTRS, Executive
Director at (703) 683-9420 or national@atra-tr.org.
Sincerely,
e/s
Ann D. Huston, MPA, CTRS
ATRA Executive Director
Cc: Peter Thomas,
ATRA Legislative Counsel
Sandra Fitzler, American Health Care Association
ATRA Board of Directors
|